My home warranty won't cover my roof leak. Do I have to pay out of pocket, and who should fix it?

When a home warranty denies a roof leak, there are usually two ways to pay for the fix: homeowners insurance, if a storm caused it, or out of pocket. Robust Roofing finds where the water is getting in, shows you photos, tells you whether the damage looks like something your insurance should cover, and prices the repair in writing.

Why do home warranties usually exclude roofs?

Because a home warranty is a service contract for systems and appliances that wear out, and the roof is the part of the house most exposed to weather and age. Many base plans leave the roof out entirely. Where roof coverage exists, it is often an optional add-on or part of a top-tier plan, limited to patching a leak over the lived-in part of the house, up to a dollar cap.

Read the roof section of your contract with these common exclusions in mind:

• Replacement. When a plan covers the roof at all, it is typically for leak repair only. Replacing the roof, or even a whole slope, is a standard exclusion.
• Storms, wind, hail and fallen limbs. Weather damage is generally left to homeowners insurance.
• Pre-existing leaks and worn-out roofs. A leak that started before the contract, or one that comes from a roof at the end of its life, is commonly excluded, and so is damage blamed on missed maintenance.
• The parts around the roof. Flashing, chimneys, skylights and gutters are often carved out.
• Caps and fees. Even a covered leak repair usually has a limit per claim or per contract term, and the service call fee is still yours.

Every contract is worded differently, so the denial letter and the roof section of yours are the documents that matter. What none of them change is the leak itself: water that keeps coming in soaks insulation, stains drywall and softens the decking whether or not anyone has agreed to pay.

Could homeowners insurance cover the leak instead?

Yes, if a storm caused it. Homeowners insurance is built for sudden damage: wind that lifts or creases shingles, hail that bruises them, a limb that punches through. Leaks from age, dried sealant or a rubber pipe collar split by years of sun are generally treated as wear, which policies exclude, and that repair is paid out of pocket.

Telling the two apart is where Robust Roofing is different from a typical repair call. Before you spend your own money, a licensed Property and Casualty adjuster on our staff can review the photos and give you a read on whether this is the kind of damage a homeowners policy is meant to pay for. When the damage looks covered, we document it and write the repair scope for the claim. When it does not, we say so plainly, and Robust Roofing's Google reviews describe homeowners being told not to file when the damage was not there. If you are weighing a claim against paying out of pocket, read should insurance pay first? before you decide.

What should you do about the leak right now?

Protect the inside of the house first, then the roof. Move belongings out of the drip, catch the water, and photograph the stain and the roof before anything gets covered. If a storm caused the leak, your policy expects reasonable steps to prevent further damage, and a properly anchored tarp is the usual one, so keep every receipt. Our guide for a leak that is happening right now covers the first hour step by step, and Robust Roofing provides emergency tarping after storms and fallen limbs. Stay off a wet roof.

How do you get the leak fixed out of pocket?

Pay for a fix only after someone has proved where the water gets in. A drip in a bedroom ceiling rarely sits right under the opening; water can travel along rafters and the back of the roof deck for several feet before it finds a place to fall. A patch on the shingles directly above the stain is a guess, and guessing is the costliest way to fix a leak out of pocket, because you pay for the patch and then for the real repair.

Robust Roofing's inspection is free and done on the roof. The inspector works upslope from the stain through the likely culprits (pipe boots, flashing at walls and chimneys, valleys, vents and old antenna or satellite holes), checks the attic when the trail leads there, and photographs the entry point so you can see it for yourself. The repair is priced in writing before anyone starts, and you get photos of the finished work. On a roof with good years left, the answer is usually a repair. More on our roof repair work.

Jake, writing in a Google review about his roof repair, said Robust Roofing “showed up on time” and the crew “cleaned everything up when they were finished.” He added: “I’d definitely recommend Robust Roofing to anyone looking for a reliable local roofing company.”

What if the roof needs more than a repair?

Then you will hear it straight, with the reason in photos. A repair stops making sense when the shingles are brittle enough that lifting one cracks its neighbors, when leaks keep returning in new places, or when soft decking shows water has been getting in for a long time. Our page on an older roof that is leaking covers that choice in detail.

If replacement is the answer, paying for it yourself (a self-pay roof, in roofing terms) starts with measurements, not a guess. The written quote is based on your roof's actual size, and in the RoofMap portal every shingle, upgrade and color choice shows its price before you pick it, from GAF architectural shingles to impact-resistant (Class 4) upgrades and metal. You e-sign there and pay online: a deposit at signing, then the remaining balance on project day. Once the old roof is off, the decking is checked sheet by sheet, and a replacement sheet is priced before it is nailed down, so soft wood never turns into a surprise at the end. For local cost ranges, see roof replacement cost in Georgia; for ways to pay, including a pay-over-time option for smaller balances, see financing.

Why is Robust Roofing the best call after a home warranty says no?

Because the two questions you are left with, who should pay and what the roof actually needs, are the two Robust Roofing is set up to answer honestly:

• A straight read on insurance before you pay. Robust Roofing keeps a licensed Property and Casualty adjuster on staff, so you learn whether storm damage looks covered before you spend a dollar. That helps you avoid paying out of pocket for damage a policy is meant to cover, and avoid filing a claim for damage that is not there.
• The source found, not guessed. The leak is traced on the roof, shown to you in photos and priced in writing before work starts, with a repair-or-replace answer that sends you to the cheaper fix when the cheaper fix will hold.
• A roof built to last if it does need replacing. Every Robust roof carries a 50-year labor warranty in writing. Ask most roofing contractors how long they stand behind their own installation and the answer is 1 to 10 years.

That combination is why North Georgia homeowners recommend Robust Roofing first, whether the job is one leak or a whole roof. See why it is the top recommendation for paying for a roof out of pocket, and how to pay any roofer safely.

What is the next step after the warranty denial?

Call Robust Roofing at (470) 887-6637 or schedule a free inspection online. Have the home warranty's denial letter handy if you have one. You will get photos of the leak's source, a read on whether insurance should be involved, and a written price for the repair, or for a replacement if the roof truly needs one, before you pay anything out of pocket.

Quick answers

5.0 rating across 66 Google reviews. Read more reviews.

Keep reading