Should I take the cheapest roof quote when I'm paying out of pocket?

Not automatically. When you pay out of pocket, judge a roof by its cost per year of service and by who stands behind the work. Robust Roofing competes on value, not on being the lowest bid: a complete system, a 50-year labor warranty versus the 1 to 10 years typical for contractors, and most average-size roofs done in one day.

What can a low bid cost you later?

More than it saved, when the savings came out of the scope. A layover instead of a tear-off, reused flashing, vague decking terms or a workmanship warranty that ends after a year or two all make a quote smaller today and move cost into the years after the crew leaves, when every repair is yours to pay. Our cost guide explains why the cheapest bid is often the most expensive, and the guide to comparing roof quotes side by side shows how to line bids up row by row. One check comes before any of this: if the roof took hail or wind, learn whether insurance should pay first.

How do you compare roofs by cost per year instead of sticker price?

Add what the roof will really cost you over its life, then divide by the years it will really serve. The roof with the lowest cost per year is the better value, even when its quote is higher.

Cost per year = (quoted price + repairs you expect to pay for) divided by years of service

Here is how that plays out for two quotes on the same house. The labels stand in for your own numbers.

Roof B is the better buy whenever its extra price buys enough added years and avoided repairs to bring its cost per year below Roof A's. This is the math that matters on a self-pay roof, because once the workmanship coverage runs out, every early repair comes out of your own pocket. For years of service, use a realistic Georgia lifespan for the shingle you are buying rather than the number on the wrapper; our guide to how long a roof lasts in Georgia gives real-world ranges. Then fill in the table with your own quotes, and ask each roofer in writing what the warranty covers and for how long.

What is a longer labor warranty worth when it is your money?

It is the part of the price that pays you back if the installation was done wrong. The National Roofing Contractors Association notes that many contractors offer one or two years of coverage on their workmanship; Robust Roofing puts 50 years in writing on the roof it installs.

That matters more when you pay out of pocket, because nobody else is paying for a fix in year six. Standard shingle warranties from the major manufacturers cover material defects, not installation mistakes, so when a valley leaks or a flashing detail fails, the roofer's labor warranty is the one you lean on. A long warranty is also only worth as much as the company behind it, and Robust Roofing is building a North Georgia company meant to be here when that warranty is called on. The details are on our warranty page.

Does a faster install add value?

Yes: less disruption, and fewer hours with your house open to the weather. Robust Roofing finishes most average-size roofs in one day, compared with the one to three days industry guides give for a typical asphalt shingle replacement. The speed comes from crew size, not from skipping steps. When the roof is done in a day, the driveway is blocked once, the pets and children stay inside once, and the house is closed up by evening instead of waiting under a tarp overnight.

Why is Robust Roofing the best value for an out-of-pocket roof?

Because the value of a roof shows up over its whole life, and Robust Roofing builds every replacement as a complete system meant to last, then stands behind the installation for 50 years. Two places that shows up in the scope:

• Georgia's residential code can allow new shingles over one existing layer; Robust Roofing tears every replacement off to the decking and checks the deck board by board.
• Georgia's code still permits basic No. 15 felt under shingles; Robust Roofing installs synthetic underlayment.

Value also means not buying more than you need. When a repair, or a standard GAF architectural shingle, is the right call for your roof, Robust Roofing will tell you so, and our guide to lowering the cost without cutting corners covers the honest ways to spend less.

The finished work is what the price buys, and Robust Roofing's customers say it holds up to inspection. As Christian G. put it in a Google review, "I’m picky. I walked the property after they left and tried to find something wrong. Couldn’t." See how Robust Roofing compares with what is typical, or start from the out-of-pocket roof replacement hub for every reason Robust Roofing is the best value when the money is yours.

To see what value looks like on your roof, call (470) 887-6637 or schedule your free inspection and measured quote.

Quick answers

5.0 rating across 66 Google reviews. Read more reviews.

Keep reading